While nobody has officially come out and said what this song is about exactly, since the album’s release, a lot of people have theorized that this song is about the duo’s feelings for each other. More specifically, many believe the song is about one still having romantic feelings for the other (side note for those who just got here: Scott and Mitch did date in high school, and almost tried again during the Sing Off). Most people speculate that the song is from Mitch’s point of view, but the opposite can also be easily argued.